News Portal

Haj deaths present problem of protecting pilgrims from scorching local weather


Muslim pilgrims holding umbrellas stroll on the third day of the Satan stoning ritual, amid extraordinarily sizzling climate, throughout the annual haj pilgrimage, in Mina, Saudi Arabia, on June 18, 2024.
| Photo Credit: Reuters

Hundreds of the pilgrims who died in fierce warmth at this yr’s haj weren’t formally registered with the Saudi authorities, with the end result that many had no entry to very important providers like air-conditioned buses and cool-off tents.

The deaths spotlight a looming problem for organisers as local weather change takes maintain within the area: the follow of requiring official permits for such providers is stirring concern that unregistered pilgrims might more and more be uncovered to life-threatening temperatures.

At the identical time, excessive costs for official haj packages are driving some Muslims to take cheaper unofficial routes to the ritual, though these lack the essential permits, and to use an easing of curbs on another sorts of Saudi visas.

The unregistered pilgrims’ lack of a allow made it tough to offer them with providers and care, the safety spokesman for Saudi’s Ministry of Interior, Colonel Talal bin Shalhoub, stated in an interview on Saudi TV channel al-Arabiya.

Critics of the federal government say all pilgrims, no matter their standing, must be protected against warmth, and allege the authorities this yr cracked down on unauthorised attendees.

“This focus on registered visit versus unregistered is a red herring … If you are there and you need help, you should get access to it,” stated Khalid al-Jabri, a doctor who labored for the Saudi safety company that oversees haj and is at present a part of the Saudi opposition in exile.

Saudi Arabia’s worldwide media workplace didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark.

Saudi Arabia’s well being minister, Fahad Al-Jalajel stated in an announcement that well being authorities offered providers to unregistered pilgrims on 141,000 events throughout the haj.

Heat stroke danger

But he acknowledged that unregistered pilgrims “walked long distances under direct sunlight without adequate shelter or comfort”, and added that 83% of the 1,301 fatalities have been amongst unregistered pilgrims.

Pilgrims stated these with out permits needed to stroll at occasions in temperatures above 50 levels Celsius (122 Fahrenheit), whereas most registered pilgrims have been capable of make a lot of the journey by air-conditioned bus.

A Reuters witness stated he noticed 1000’s strolling on the freeway close to Mina, an enormous tent metropolis on the best way to Mecca, slightly than utilizing buses like most registered pilgrims. Pilgrims informed Reuters that Saudi officers routinely checked buses earlier than departure to make sure solely registered pilgrims have been aboard.

Almost two million pilgrims made their technique to Mecca this yr to carry out haj rites as taught by the Prophet Mohammad to his followers 14 centuries in the past.

It just isn’t recognized how large the inflow of unauthorised pilgrims was. But Saudi Director of Public Security Mohammed bin Abdullah al-Bassami stated this month the dominion had deported 171,587 individuals who weren’t residents of Mecca, in obvious reference to individuals caught attempting to carry out haj and not using a allow. Heat-related deaths alongside the haj will not be new, however local weather change has made haj more and more harmful.

A 2021 research discovered that if the world warms by 1.5 C (2.7 F) above pre-industrial ranges, warmth stroke danger for pilgrims on the haj will probably be 5 occasions higher. The world is on observe to succeed in 1.5 C of warming within the 2030s.

“It’s a situation that is only getting worse with time,” stated Elfatih Eltahir, co-director of the Jameel Observatory and a professor at MIT, who printed a paper on the risks of warmth stress for pilgrims in 2019.

Seeking spiritual vacationers

Despite such worrying local weather projections, Saudi Arabia has stated it desires to increase the numbers of spiritual vacationers, aiming to welcome 30 million pilgrims for haj and the year-round pilgrimage umra yearly by 2030, as a part of its broader technique to wean the financial system off oil.

In 2019, Saudi Arabia earned about $12 billion yearly from haj and umra, in accordance official information.

Haj excursions can value from $5,000 to $10,000 per individual, and the value is a part of the rationale many take unofficial packages.

“Finances are…a huge factor,” stated Khaled El Sherbini, the proprietor of an Egypt-based tour company. He stated an Egyptian might do haj “unregistered” for 30,000 or 40,000 EGP ($622-$829), a fraction of an official package deal costing about 300,000 EGP ($6,222.78). In 2018 a haj package deal would have value about $3,000.

The kingdom is decided to guard official haj packages. Ahead of the pilgrimage, its inside ministry stated these caught transporting an unregistered pilgrim would withstand six months in jail and a tremendous of as much as 50,000 riyals ($13,000).

An Egyptian disaster unit tasked with investigating the deaths of Egyptian pilgrims stated on Saturday it suspended licences of 16 tourism corporations and referred them for prosecution.

Pilgrims who purchased lower-end packages informed Reuters they have been packed into crowded tents with 80 to 200 individuals and restricted cooling. Alia Asma, an Indian pilgrim, stated that she needed to stroll longer distances than those that purchased dearer excursions.

“The rich can afford luxurious apartments and the poor come into the tents,” stated Irhan al-Alawi, the manager director of the Islamic Heritage Research Foundation.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More